L’outil de licence Creative Commons du formulaire de soumission ne fonctionne pas actuellement. Pour ajouter une licence CC à votre thèse ou publication, contactez ruor@uottawa.ca après le dépôt. -- The Creative Commons licence tool in the submission form is currently unavailable. To apply a CC licence to your thesis or publication, contact ruor@uottawa.ca after the deposit.

Corporate Human Rights Accountability in Nigeria's Extractive Sector: Towards a Citizen-Centered Remedy Mechanism

En cours de chargement...
Vignette d'image

Nom de la revue

ISSN de la revue

Titre du volume

Éditeur

Université d'Ottawa / University of Ottawa

Résumé

This research examines the constraints on access to remedy for corporate human rights violations in Nigeria's petroleum sector and proposes citizen-centered participatory approaches to strengthen the implementation of Pillar III of the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Despite comprehensive legal frameworks and international commitments, victims of corporate human rights violations in Nigeria's oil sector face systematic barriers to accessing effective remedies. The research identifies a fundamental remedy gap where formal legal mechanisms exist but fail to provide meaningful redress to affected communities. State-based judicial mechanisms remain largely inaccessible due to prohibitive litigation costs, complex procedural requirements, and judicial attitudes favoring corporate interests. Non-judicial mechanisms, including regulatory agencies and corporate grievance procedures, suffer from institutional weaknesses, insufficient funding, and lack of independence from corporate influence. Most significantly, existing remedy mechanisms systematically exclude affected communities from meaningful participation in remedy design, implementation, and monitoring, perpetuating power asymmetries between multinational corporations and local communities. The study employs a multidisciplinary methodology combining doctrinal legal analysis, systematic gap analysis, and comparative analysis. Key findings reveal systematic failures across Nigeria's remedy mechanisms that collectively deny effective redress to oil-affected communities. Key findings reveal that Nigeria's constitutional framework renders environmental rights non-justiciable, statutory mechanisms lack meaningful community participation provisions, and judicial patterns demonstrate systematic barriers, including prohibitive costs, restrictive standing requirements, and weak enforcement. Based on the findings, the primary contribution of this research is the development of a comprehensive Citizen-Centered Participatory Framework (CCPF) that transforms remedy provision from top-down, state-controlled processes to community-empowered mechanism. The proposed framework integrates five core models: (1) Enhanced Access to Information Systems with community-controlled monitoring; (2) Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) as both preventive and remedial mechanism; (3) Community-controlled Impact and Benefit Agreements (IBAs); (4) Community-Led Environmental Monitoring networks; and (5) Participatory Grievance Mechanisms incorporating restorative justice approaches. The proposed CCPF addresses these gaps by establishing community ownership of remedy processes, multi-dimensional approaches addressing individual, collective, and structural harms, and integration with UN Working Group effectiveness criteria for legitimacy, accessibility, predictability, equity, transparency, rights-compatibility, and continuous learning. The research concludes that implementing citizen-centered approaches can transform corporate accountability from voluntary compliance frameworks toward enforceable community-driven remedy systems. This transformation requires constitutional reform, legislative amendments, institutional capacity building, and sustained political commitment to genuine participatory governance. The study provides practical policy recommendations for operationalizing the framework within Nigeria's 2023 National Action Plan on Business and Human Rights while contributing to broader theoretical understanding of remedy mechanisms in extractive industry contexts.

Description

Mots-clés

Citizen centered remedy, Access to remedy, UN Guiding Principle, Extractive industry, Nigeria, Citizen-Centered Participatory Framework, Business and human rights

Citation

Approbation

Évaluation

Complété par

Référencé par