Social Anxiety Among Canadian Undergraduate Students: An Analysis of Symptom Trends, Severity, and Experiences over the Years.
En cours de chargement...
Date
Authors
Nom de la revue
ISSN de la revue
Titre du volume
Éditeur
Université d'Ottawa | University of Ottawa
Résumé
The two following studies sought to better understand the social anxiety experience among Canadian undergraduate students. Social anxiety (SA) is characterized by fear or anxiety in social situations that carry the potential for negative evaluation from others. People typically avoid the anxiety-inducing social interaction or endure it with distress. Not only can SA be incredibly impairing, but it is also one of the most common mental health challenges. Challenges with SA occur more among young adults than other age groups, and are therefore prevalent among undergraduate students, who must navigate numerous novel social demands. Understanding symptom severity of SA over time and symptom presentation in this population is crucial to better inform mental health resource allocation. In Study 1, I addressed claims that mental health difficulties are worsening by examining social anxiety symptom severity across time among Canadian undergraduate students. I conducted a systematic review of studies that reported SA mean scores among this population using PRISMA-P guidelines. Two independent reviewers engaged in article screening, data extraction, and quality assessment, and I ultimately included articles that were in English or French, used a Canadian sample of undergraduate students, were empirical articles or theses, included individual data sets, and reported a mean score of SA and its standard deviation with the use of a well-validated SA measure (i.e., good psychometric properties, repeatedly validated). Next, I ran a series of meta-analyses and meta-regressions based on the 149 articles found in the search using the most commonly used measures of SA according to the systematic review (Social Interaction Anxiety Scale: 26 samples; Social Phobia Scale: 19 samples; Social Phobia Inventory: 14 samples; Leibowitz Social Anxiety Scale: 7 samples). I found that the mean SA score increased significantly over time only on the Social Phobia Inventory, yielding a very small increase. Methodological factors that may have impacted these results are discussed. The findings further suggested that although SA severity does not appear to be increasing among Canadian undergraduate students, many report SA symptoms above the clinical threshold. Furthermore, the Covid-19 pandemic had significant mental health impacts worldwide. Quantitative research suggests increased social anxiety symptoms in adults during the pandemic, without a clear understanding of the experience. The unique experience of intersecting social demands of undergraduate studies and their stage of emerging adulthood, requires a more nuanced understanding of whether social anxiety is worsening, how undergraduates are coping, and how the pandemic has impacted symptoms and experiences. In Study 2, I conducted a qualitative study to gain an in-depth understanding of how socially anxious students (Social Phobia Inventory Score>15) experienced the pandemic (including lockdowns and return to in-person learning) during their undergraduate studies. Students were recruited via online ads and a pre-existing lab database. I included 14 semi-structured interviews (x̄ age = 21.28 years, SD = 1.13; 10 women, 2 men, 2 non-binary) in the reflexive thematic analysis. The average SPIN score was above clinical threshold with more than half of participants scoring in the severe or very severe social anxiety range. Using reflexive thematic analysis, we generated 6 themes and 18 subthemes centered around social engagement, academic success, support, identity, and pandemic-related symptoms. Our findings suggest that Canadian undergraduate students are not only experiencing high levels of social anxiety symptoms, but also that the pandemic heightened these symptoms in a multitude of ways across various domains. Overall, in the last several years, Canadian undergraduate students have consistently experienced elevated social anxiety symptoms. The pandemic may have maintained or heightened these symptoms, affecting many areas of life. While many are starting to return to pre-pandemic experiences, challenges with identity, socialization, and academics are presented in new, challenging ways. These findings highlight a population with unique needs compared to other age groups and differing demands, and who have experienced heightened distress in the wake of a pandemic. As such, we must consider how this added understanding impacts current theoretical models, clinical approaches, and use of tools (e.g., technology) at this stage of life.
Description
Mots-clés
Social anxiety, Undergraduate students, Pandemic, Mental health, Meta-analysis, Qualitative
