Systemic Quinolones and Risk of Adverse Reactions: Integrating Evidence from Clinical and Epidemiological Evidence Streams

Abstract

Quinolones are a group of antibiotics that have gained significant popularity on a global scale since the end of the last century. This popularity was predominantly based on their proven potency, broad coverage against a wide range of bacteria, in addition to possessing a favorable pharmacologic profile. Whereas quinolone-associated adverse reactions are generally tolerable and self-limiting, some reactions have generated heightened concerns due to their serious nature, which have resulted in label changes or even market withdrawal in some instances. This thesis investigates the association between quinolone antibiotics and two adverse reactions of an acute and serious nature: acute liver failure and retinal detachment. Each adverse reaction is investigated through integrating evidence from three studies utilizing different designs based on data from different sources, with each source offering a unique perspective on this issue. The first study type (chapter 2 for acute liver failure ‘ALF’ and Chapter 5 for retinal detachment ‘RD’) analyzes spontaneous reports submitted to the US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) adverse event reporting system database. Chapters 3 and 6 systematically identified all relevant (published and unpublished) clinical trials for occurrences of ALF and RD, respectively, among trial participants. Finally, chapters 4 (ALF) and 7 (RD) involved case-control analysis of a major US database of electronic health records for nearly 70 million inpatients admitted to more than 500 hospitals between 2000 and 2016.

The FAERS analysis revealed a positive ALF signal with ciprofloxacin and a marginal signal for RD with moxifloxacin. Examination of the evidence from clinical trials revealed only two cases of ALF, one associated with gemifloxacin and one with moxifloxacin. No cases of RD were reported in any of the identified clinical trials. Primary analyses of the Health Facts® data revealed no overall association between quinolones and the risk of ALF or RD. However, elevated risk was identified in some subgroups, including African Americans (ALF, RD), Caucasians (ALF), women (ALF, RD), men (ALF), those ≤60 years of age (ALF) or 56-70 years of age (RD), and those with no or few comorbidities (ALF).

Evidence from analyses of data from spontaneous reports and clinical trials provided some evidence for an elevated risk of ALF or RD following the systemic administration of quinolone antibiotics. Some evidence of elevated risk was also identified in the case-control analyses of inpatient EHR records. Findings from our six epidemiologic studies are in line with current advisories by FDA and Health Canada.