Nurses' Moral Experiences of Ethically Meaningful Situations in End-of-Life Care

Abstract

Nursing ethics in end-of-life care is often framed in reference to dramatic moral dilemmas and resulting moral distress that nurses experience in practice. While important, this framing obscures the moral significance of nurses’ everyday practice. The purpose of this study was to explore nurses’ moral experiences of palliative and end-of-life care, including situations that are enriching. The research question was: What are the moral experiences of nurses engaged in ethically meaningful situations in end-of-life care? Semi-structured interviews were conducted with five nurses from across Canada who practice in settings where palliative and/or end-of-life care are an important part of their role. Informed by interpretive description and a theoretical scaffold about nurses’ moral practice, a descriptive and thematic analysis of the data was performed. The participants described ethical challenges relating to patient autonomy, futility, prognostication, and navigating requests for medical assistance in dying. Experiences that were ethically enriching involved situations where the nurse, patient, and family worked together to create a peaceful and dignified death. Taken together, the participants’ narratives revealed them as morally engaged in their everyday practice, where such moral engagement is both reflective and relational. This study expands understanding about how nurses’ stories of end-of-life care reveal their capacity for moral sensitivity. This study also contributes to the articulation of a theoretical lens for examining the moral dimensions of nursing work. By explicating the relational dimensions of ethically meaningful experiences, including relationships with wider structures that facilitate and constrain the possibility for ethical action, this theoretical lens can support researchers to think creatively about palliative and end-of-life nursing from an explicitly ethical perspective.